Both of my playtest tables killed Voss. They had made up their minds about him before he opened the door, and they saw no other way. Voss was never going to change. He enjoys his work. What I didn't give them was a way to win the argument anyway.
I recently stumbled my way into creating a method that I use when an NPC wants to argue. I give them three entries.
- Says: This is what the NPC will say out loud, in their own words.
- Won't Say: What they hide from everyone, sometimes even themselves.
- Gives Way If: How they can end the argument and still save face.
Here is Voss when I reworked him using this method.
Says: "You've come about the spring. I am open to returning her name... for a trade. Not for coin, mind. Though I'm not sure why she would want to. What I do preserves the essence for all time."
Won't Say: He has spent years refusing to comprehend why he sets tea at his table for two. It is a ritual, there is no meaning behind it... So he claims. He won't say why he won't examine his own motives more thoroughly.
Gives Way If: A trade for a secret, a name, an essence, something forgotten, or an argument regarding his ethics. He will not change his behavior, but he does find it curious that people fret so much over what equates to immortality for him. He adds this curiosity to his own collection.
This works really well when applied to Daggerheart Compatible games. The system already uses Social Adversaries: NPCs who present a challenging conversation as opposed to a fight. These Adversaries already include a Motives & Tactics section in their stat block. These three lines are just a more robust way of writing that for a chatty NPC. "Gives Way If" helps you set the difficulty for the conversation. Before the condition is met, expect a higher difficulty. Once it's met, the conversation gets easier.
So that's it for this method! Try it out at your table and let me know how it goes. Who's the best NPC you wrote that the table didn't fully engage with?
Want more NPC writing tips? I fit everything I need to play an NPC on one index card. Here's how.
My free one shot, Where the Watermint Grows, can be found here.
Daggerheart™ Compatible. Terms at Daggerheart.com. Evenreach Games is not affiliated with Darrington Press or Critical Role, LLC.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.